Unhype: a newsletter for coaches • COACHILLY MAG by COACHILLY MAG

All issues

Hot leads turn cold after looking you up?

Find the leak and get 13 great examples to inspire you

Unhype by COACHILLY MAG

 

Hey Coach,

 

Today: how you can win a lead and lose it again in a single day.

 

THIS WEEK

Sarah, an EQI coach, spoke at a mid-sized event last week. Her audience was leaning in. Right after the event, a woman named Lydia took her business card and said, "This is fantastic. I'll follow up with you."

 

That night Lydia opened Sarah's website on her phone. Sarah built that site four years ago, for a slightly different niche. What Sarah talked about on stage that night wasn't reflected on it. The dots didn't connect. Lydia still wanted to talk, but she also couldn't find an easy way to book a call. So she closed the app.

 

What happened to Sarah happens to a lot of coaches. People don't stop liking you or lose interest in your area of expertise. But if your site doesn't sound like the person they met, and they can't find the thing that made them lean in, they vanish. People form an opinion of a website's look in 50 milliseconds, according to a 2006 study from Carleton University.

Keep reading

Enter your email to finish this story and get COACHILLY MAG's next one straight to your inbox.

Already subscribed? Enter the same address and you'll go straight through. · Free, and you can unsubscribe any time.

Share

More issues

All 58 →
#57 Oct 9, 2026

Turn your practice insights into PR

Read issue →
#56 Oct 1, 2026

Is AI making your brand look generic?

Read issue →