In It To End It by Sean Oakes

All issues

Tonight: Wise Consumption & Attention; last week: Ethics-based Eating

Recordings from last week's Satsang, and teaching notes.

image


Friends,


I saw a good meme this week about not letting your alarm and overwhelm about what's happening politically derail your basic life maintenance and self-care. That no matter what's happening out there it's still important to take care of the seeming small things in your immediate care, like watering your plants. The funny-not-funny punchline was that if you don't, "then you'll have fascism and dead plants."


There is so much happening in the media that we can forget what it was like when we didn't have minute-by-minute news about the machinations of the court and the empire. I've been listening to history podcasts lately, along with reading the great Chinese medieval novel, The Journey to the West, and the dialogues of Plato (sorry, I know...), and one of the things that's apparent in the study of history, of course, is that the court and the empire behave in predictable and repetitive ways. We are in a moment where the court intrigue is intense, and the actions of the mad king are destabilizing both the domestic and international order. This has happened so many times before, with the main characters almost stock theatrical archetypes.


During all tumultuous times, the actions of those in power eventually impact nearly everyone, and already we are seeing impacts on so many vulnerable people, from farmers and immigrant workers to vulnerable people in war zones around the world, and on and on. But at the same time, much of the drama is smoke and flashing lights, and if you missed reading the news for a couple days the day today life you are immersed in would be strangely quiet and what we call "normal." You take care of your body and your family, make food, clean the house, do your work, and try to be kind and generous to the people around you.


It is possible to live an ordinary life through extraordinary times. The politicized radical rebuttal to that is that because other people are living through incredibly traumatic experiences, those of us who are not are by the nature of our compassion compelled to also stay close to that trauma. I think this is partly true and partly not. It is indeed the discipline of Kuan Yin to persistently listen to the cries of the world and radiate compassion, and the active expression of that compassion must be doing what we can to help. But there is a difference between this kind of spiritually-motivated engagement and an obsessive tracking of the empire that primarily serves to maintain our anxiety and overwhelm.


There's lots of good advice right now on not giving into overwhelm. Remember that you don't have to track everything that's happening—choose one or two issues and focus there. Remember that there are experts and professionals engaging in this fight as part of their livelihood, who have more time and resources to give to something that you do—so it's more helpful to support them than to think that you have to invent a new resistance movement in your living room with your friends (even as we know that that's where all the resistance movements start). And there's just watering your plants, getting to the gym, answering important emails, and getting nourishing food on the table. Keeping yourself healthy, well slept, and nourished by pleasure and good friendship is one of the strongest gestures you can make to support the well-being of our country and communities in both the short and long run.


Tonight at Satsang we'll continue with our "Dharma Life Reset" series, moving on from sleep and food to our wider patterns of consumption—part of "Right Livelihood" in Buddhist terms—and look at our participation in the consumer economy, including the economy where our attention is the most valuable commodity and we ourselves are bought and sold for the profit of the oligarchs. Stay safe and see you soon.


With mettā,

Sean




From Satsang, Tue 2.4.25

Ethics-based Eating Practices: Vegan & Eco-systemic

Last week discussing Buddhist ideas about eating meat we went right up to the bell, and of course there are questions, anxieties, cultural issues, and strong views and opinions about this topic that we didn't get to. So tonight I invited questions and discussion on the topic, beginning with a short talk outlining two approaches to the ethics of eating.


The strongest views on ethical eating in North American culture tend to come from folks committed to vegan diets, who hold variations of the view than any kind of meat-eating or using animal bodies as resources in many ways is unethical. This is a beautiful, Dharma-supported view, and I appreciate the clarity of it.


As we touched on last week, there are other ways of interpreting the Buddha's instruction to not take life, including systems-level approaches to participation with the global economy that look at the harms caused by human exploitation of natural resources broadly, not just on animal life.


These different approaches are not just variations in how we interpret the first precept—they also indicate important differences in our fundamental view of what it means to be a sentient being worthy of protection. Vegan practice emphasizes the individual sentience of animals, which is an important corrective to the common idea that animals are a "resource" at all, rather than our kin and neighbors on the planet.


Eco-systemic approaches often emphasize a more Animist world view that doesn't separate the plant and animal kingdoms into discrete orders of sentience. If we understand everything as possessing a kind of self and consciousness, as an Animist view suggests, the killing of an individual animal is different from the killing of a plant in degree but not in kind (and even that distinction is philosophically tenuous). This is how some Indigenous societies think about meat, and is behind the many rituals often woven around killing and eating.


What I want us to hold in this discussion is awareness of how our underlying worldview conditions our ideas about what actions are ethical and which are not. This has profound implications for every aspect of how we live together on our planet. We looked as well at some other conditions potentially affecting our views on eating and ability to pursue practices of food choice, including economic class and ancestral heritage. As in all contentious social topics, we are looking for any place where our views about how things are is creating unnecessary suffering for ourselves, our neighbors, and the planet we share.


Meditation: Compassion for All Kinds of Beings


Talk: About Eating (Meat, and Otherwise)



Teaching Schedule

Rebuild Your Attention: Buddhist Practices for Focus, Clarity, and Joy

A 5-week study class at New York Insight

5 Thursdays, Feb 27 – Mar 27, 2025 | 3:30-5pm PT | Online

Register


Deepening Practice: Quieting Our Minds and Opening our Hearts in Community

Gay Buddhist Fellowship Spring Retreat for queer male-identified practitioners

Apr 23-27, 2025 | Vajrapani Institute

Register


See All



Dāna

Our ability to offer as much as we can in this beautiful tradition of gift economy depends on your support. Your gifts make scholarships possible for those with less resources to attend retreat, support our preservation of the teaching archive, and make it possible for us to offer everything we do as accessibly as possible. Thank you.


Donate Here



Ongoing Saṅgha Spaces

Insight Meditation Satsang

Tuesdays 7:30-9pm (Pacific), weekly

Meditation, talk, discussion


Book Club: Read the Dīgha Nikāya, the Long Discourses of the Buddha

Fridays 8:30-10am (Pacific), monthly

Talk, inquiry, discussion

Next session: Feb 21


In It To End It

Saṅgha Facebook group

Recordings, discussion, Q & A

All are welcome


May our practice be of benefit to all.



SeanFeitOakes.com


YouTube | Insight Timer | Instagram

Share
Get the next issue in your inbox
Free, and you can unsubscribe any time.

0 comments

More issues

All 95 →
#29 Feb 4, 2025

Lunar New Year, Why I'm (Still) Vegetarian, and we're in a Coup?

Read issue →
#28 Jan 27, 2025

What Does Health Feel Like? Being Food, Being Earth

Read issue →