In It To End It by Sean Oakes

All issues

Next Book Club: Friday, Oct 17 | Dependent Origination, Selves (Not), and Rebirth

Where does all the bad stuff in the world come from? Craving, craving, craving.

Hi friends,


Our next book club meeting will be Friday, Oct 17, 8:30-10am.


This month we're reading The Great Discourse on Causation (DN 15). In it, the Buddha teaches Ānanda about Dependent Origination (paṭiccasamuppāda). This is the main discourse that teaches D.O. in detail outside of the chapter of the Connected Discourses (Saṁyutta Nikāya 12) devoted to it. The basic sequence can be read at SN 12.1, with the terms defined at SN 12.2, and further interesting explorations of it through the subsequent short suttas.


In DN 15, the Buddha first teaches the links in reverse order, then forward, as is common. An interesting departure happens at section 9.1, where the Buddha elaborates on craving with a list of 9 things that have craving as their cause:


So it is, Ānanda, that feeling gives rise to craving. Craving gives rise to searching. Searching gives rise to gaining material things. Gaining material things gives rise to evaluation. Evaluation gives rise to desire and lust. Desire and lust gives rise to attachment. Attachment gives rise to ownership. Ownership gives rise to stinginess. Stinginess gives rise to safeguarding. Owing to safeguarding, many bad, unskillful things come to be: taking up the rod and the sword, quarrels, arguments, and disputes, accusations, divisive speech, and lies. (DN 15.9.1)


This is a beautiful way of tracing social ills and violence back to craving and linking them to the sequence of Dependent Origination. As in many versions of D.O., the Buddha traces the links back to consciousness (viññāṇa) and name-and-form (nāma-rūpa) mutually conditioning each other, and leaves out the “first” two links of ignorance (avijjā) and kammic/volitional formations (saṅkhāra).


After the detailed exposition of D.O., the text launches into an exploration of what it means to have or be a self. This follows from the implication of D.O. that this is the process by which one “becomes” which leads to taking birth again and again. The argument ends up centering on feeling (vedaṇā) because no self can be imagined as existing without feeling, but feeling is obviously changeable and impermanent, so can’t indicate the kind of permanent entity needed to fulfill the definition of self (attā).


The text ends with the Buddha describing nine places one might be reborn, and eight “liberations” (vimokkhā), which is another way of talking about the attainment of the meditative states of the four jhāna and four āruppa, but includes some distinct ways of talking about jhāna, like a meditation based on the perception of beauty.


If you haven't yet, this would be a good opportunity to memorize the links of Dependent Origination in Pāli and English, and be able to talk or think through them in forward and reverse order. D.O., along with the four Noble Truths and the teachings on kamma, is a lens through it to understand the world, and so using it in this way is part of the practice of Right View.


Reading

The Great Discourse on Causation (DN 15)


Other Teaching

The Sure Heart: Emotion, Healing, and Buddhist Psychology

5 Thursdays, Oct 23 – Nov 20, 4-5:30pm Pacific

New York Insight and Sati Center, Online


Blessings in your practice and see you soon.


With mettā,

Sean


Saṅgha Access

Course page


In It To End It Book Club: Reading the Dīgha Nikāya

Friday, Oct 17, 2025

8:30am – 10am (Pacific)

(11:30am – 1pm EST, 5:30pm – 7pm CET)


SeanFeitOakes.com

facebook.com/groups/in.it.to.end.it

Share
Get the next issue in your inbox
Free, and you can unsubscribe any time.

0 comments

More issues

All 95 →
#68 Oct 10, 2025

Greed and Hatred, beginningless... but not endless!

Read issue →
#67 Oct 10, 2025

How are you doing post-retreat?

Read issue →