In It To End It by Sean Oakes

All issues

Andrea Gibson, Joanna Macy, kamma, nibbāna...

image


Friends,


At the heart of the Buddha's teaching on kamma is the interpretation that came to him after meditative visions of his own innumerable past births and the rebirth destinations of others: what we experience in the future is shaped by our actions now.


Kamma is the radical rebuttal to ancient theories of both materialism—the idea that there's nothing real or meaningful happening outside of the physical forms and forces we can see and measure in the present—and nihilism, which promises that because nothing real exists for us past the death of this body, ethics is a fiction: there is no real impact of either good or bad action. The Buddha called these positions "wrong view" because they're both inaccurate to reality AND cause real harm.


While it's easy to dismiss over-simplistic definitions of these two old ideas, both are still going strong in our collective mind. Even when we see that our actions obviously have impacts, and embrace the intuition that there is a subtle world woven through and beyond the physical one, we may still get stuck on a core assumption rooted in wrong view: that we feel the way we do because of external circumstances. I feel good because I've slept well, am earning enough, have a kind partner, encountered something inspiring, participated in the resistance, or some other piece of the changing material-relational situation of our lives. I feel bad because I'm not getting those things the way I want them, and/or am getting things I don't want, like tired, sick, old, lonely, or a fascist kakistocracy.


Kamma doesn't just shape our experience through external conditions, though, and it's not even primarily about how our actions have impacts on others and the world, though clearly that's part of it. The heart of kamma is that doing good creates good futures for ourselves, and bad creates bad. Kamma in this way is not so much an affirmation of the social and political truth that our actions impact others, but a description of an inevitable reckoning we will experience for ourselves. If materialism and nihilism are attractive forms of spiritual bypass that give permission to pursue what we want regardless of our impact on others, kamma is the cold light of morning.


As we live through a time where the actions of a few powerful men are causing untold harm for much of the world, kamma is a reminder that the fate of evil is pain and misery, either in this world or the next, or both. It's not schadenfreude to bow to this truth, though there's no need to be a jerk about it either. It's just how the world turns, the Buddha says.


Far more important than what we think about the future experience of others is how this teaching affects our own intentions and choices. Whatever we are doing now, especially the choices we make about our words, work, relationships, spending, and attention—these are what create our future happiness or unhappiness, both in this lifetime and the next.


Amid the accelerating storms of social and political unrest, may your heart stay clear, and your choices healthy. Support well-being in your community however you can, and remember that no matter how dire things get, hate hurts the hater more than the object of the hatred. Kamma urges us to never abandon our future self by giving in to easy hostility and grasping at fantasy solutions.


__

This past week at Satsang we did an Ask Me Anything, and the questions were mostly on subtle doctrinal issues like kamma, emptiness, and nibbāna. Thank you, profound thinkers! (Recording below, along with the previous two weeks of Satsang where we celebrated the lives of Joanna Macy and Andrea Gibson.) So I think tonight I'll start a series looking at some of these aspects of right view.


This will be a nice balance I hope with the new study series that starts this Thursday, where we'll read the Ānāpānasati Sutta and explore mindfulness of breathing in some depth.


And we've been able to lower the registration prices for our fall retreat with Off Grid Retreats, Heart Free As a Wild Deer (Oct 1-5). Check it out.


With mettā,

Sean




From Satsang, Tue 7.29.25

AMA: Samvega, Emptiness, Nibbāna

We did an Ask Me Anything, and the questions were about saṁvega (spiritual urgency), emptiness—especially between the Pāli Canon and Zen interpretations, kamma/karma, and nibbāna. The talk moves through these, stitching them together kind of in this order. 


Reading at the end from The Record of Rinzai/Linji, or Rinzai Roku, translated by Ruth Fuller Sasaki.


Meditation: Listening to the Subtle Sound


Talk: AMA: Samvega, Emptiness, Nibbāna




From Satsang, Tue 7.22.25

Joanna Macy Becomes an Ancestor

Extraordinary Buddhist scholar, thinker, poet, translator, teacher, organizer, and grief alchemist Joanna Macy has died. She gave so much to our lineage and to the wider world, and with many of us, I'm reverent and grateful for her life in the Dhamma.


We delight in her legacy tonight, and I read from her and Anita Barrows' extraordinary translation of Rilke, which has been a precious volume for me for many years.


Poems read: Sonnets to Orpheus, poems 27 and 29; and Duino Elegies 1 and 9 from Joanna Macy and Anita Barrows, In Praise of Mortality: Selections from Rainer Maria Rilke's Duino Elegies and Sonnets to Orpheus (Riverhead, 2005).


Meditation: Sensation, Intimacy, Sensuousness


Talk: Joanna Macy Becomes an Ancestor




From Satsang, Tue 7.15.25

Awakening, Remembering, Patacāra, Andrea Gibson RIP

Reflections on the Buddha's awakening as we come through Āsāḷhā Pūjā, the July full moon that celebrates the Turning of the Wheel. Patacara's doubt in her practice and awakening poem. The meditation the Buddha found as deep intimacy with the world, and maybe even profound heartbreak as the flavor of no longer being reborn. And the wisdom and beauty of poet Andrea Gibson, who just died. Read this excerpt: 


"Cause I don’t wanna be a witness to this life,

I want to be charged and convicted,

ear lifted to her song like a bouquet of yes

because my heart is a parachute that has never opened in time

and I wanna fuck up that pattern,

leave a hole where the cold comes in and fill it every day with her sun,

‘cause anyone who has ever sat in lotus for more than a few seconds

knows it takes a hell of a lot more muscle to stay than to go"


– Andrea Gibson, Pole Dancing to Gospel Hymns


Meditation: Breathing Compassion for Yourself and the World


Talk: Awakening, Remembering, Patacāra, Andrea Gibson RIP




Teaching Schedule


Breath, Body, and Insight: Practicing With the Ānāpānasati Sutta

The Refuge of Dhamma Sutta Study Series

Aug 7 - Sep 4, 2025 | 1-3pm PT | Spirit Rock, online

Register


Heart Free as a Wild Deer

Meditation & Somatic Practice 4-night Retreat

Oct 1-5, 2025 | Off Grid Retreats at Shelterwood Collective, Cazadero, CA

Register

See All




Ongoing Saṅgha Spaces

Insight Meditation Satsang

Tuesdays 7:30-9pm (Pacific), weekly

Meditation, talk, discussion


Book Club: Read the Dīgha Nikāya, the Long Discourses of the Buddha

Fridays 8:30-10am (Pacific), monthly

Talk, inquiry, discussion

Next session: Fri Aug 22


In It To End It

Saṅgha Facebook group

Recordings, discussion, Q & A

All are welcome



Join the Saṅgha




Dāna

As a community-centered Dharma project, we believe it is imperative that tools for liberation and healing work be as accessible as possible in a time of great trouble like ours. Your support directly enables us to thrive in a Gift Economy model, where all are welcome to participate in spiritual community regardless of social position and access to material resources. Thank you!


Donate Here



May our practice be of benefit to all.




SeanFeitOakes.com

YouTube | Insight Timer | Instagram

Share
Get the next issue in your inbox
Free, and you can unsubscribe any time.

0 comments

More issues

All 95 →
#57 Jul 18, 2025

Book Club tomorrow! DN 1, part 2: eel-wrigglers, where did we come from, and where are we going?

Read issue →
#56 Jun 30, 2025

From I-Me-Mine to This-We-Nobody's

Read issue →