Blessings, friends.
This past week has been challenging for many of us, processing the result of the U.S. election. However you're feeling, I encourage you to stay close with your friends and community, and talk about it or not, but prioritize connection, rest, and grounding yourself as best you can. All empires end—the beautiful ones and the terrible ones—and change is the constant we can rely on.
That said, don't use the Dhamma to overwrite feelings of grief, rage, or fear for our shared future. How things change from here depends very much on how we all respond to the moment. I'm supported by many good voices in this moment, including Sangha friend Rebecca Solnit, whose writings in The Guardian and elsewhere are beacons of wisdom and clarity.
I've begun some writing reflecting on the election, and it's not done, but here's a first bit. I'm thinking about agency, marketing, propaganda, and what a vote means when voters are overwhelmed with lies and manipulative media. I'm feeling toward the intuition that Buddhist ideas about the nature of the individual, and of our agency, can help us make sense of this moment.
The talk from Tuesday explores this, and is linked below. Sending blessings from retreat, where we are deep in the mysterious beauty of the Perfection of Wisdom and the vast heart of benevolence it suggests. Thank you for your support of the Sangha, and I send you and your people every good blessing.
With mettā,
Sean
From Satsang, Tue 11.12.24
"Voter Agency & 'Free Will' in an Age of Propaganda"
In the days immediately following one of the most consequential, and potentially calamitous, elections in American history, it’s natural to ask why something so obviously (to you perhaps) unwholesome could come about. Why did so many people, given the facts available, choose to vote for someone whose desires, intentions, and track record promise so much suffering for so many—including the very people who voted for him?
To search for why something terrible is happening is an expression of grief and loss, and seeks wisdom, but is primarily a self-protective instinct, as our nervous system seeks the source of the danger we feel threatening those we love. Who should I be enraged at right now, my heat-seeking confusion asks? The people who voted for an amoral narcissist? The propaganda machine that fed them lies so overwhelmingly that they no longer live even close to the same narrative as most of the rest of the world? The commercial interests that fund propaganda that supports profit over truth and kindness? Maybe, yes, and absolutely, but the Dhamma asks us to look deeper, toward a more impersonal understanding of people’s agency and choices.
At the heart of democratic process, like its sibling the capitalist marketplace, is the idea that individual people have a right—and crucially, an ability—to choose their leaders, who function like products. A group of people works to convince the voting public that their person or policy is best, and then the public chooses to purchase one product or another with their vote. This idea, and most of how we think about politics/shopping, rides on the view that people have agency—free will—and some amount of independent intelligence they bring to consideration of the possibilities. It’s not coincidental that Rational Choice Theory—the idea that people consider the options and act coherently in defense of their own interests—was proposed economist Adam Smith in The Wealth of Nations in 1776. Modern democracy and modern capitalism are twins.
But “rational” choice falls apart in practice as easily as the “open” market falls apart, and for the same reason: people are not independent, rational beings who do a cost-benefit analysis of their prospective purchases and then soberly choose that which seems likely to bring the most well-being. We are impulsive, emotional, wounded, erratic, inspired. We are tribal, affected strongly by social inclusion and belonging. And most devastatingly, we are not the independent thinkers we feel like we are. We live and survive in coalitions created by stories, and our choices are not just limited by the extremely constrained options on offer in a highly centralized empire, but by the stories and information that influence our choices. Stories are how we educate and organize each other, and it is from stories that we as seeming individuals find the perspective we need to make any choice.
Meditation: Equanimity in a Difficult World
Talk: Voter Agency & "Free Will" in an Age of Propaganda
Teaching Schedule
Walking the Buddha’s Path: Meditation, Relationality, and Getting Well in an Unwell World
5 Weds, Oct 23 – Nov 20, 2024 | 9-11am PT, 12-2pm ET | New York Insight
Dāna & Volunteering
Our ability to offer as much as we can in this beautiful tradition of gift economy depends on your support. If you have the means to support our Saṅgha financially, please do so. Your gifts make scholarships possible for those with less resources to attend retreat, support our preservation of the teaching archive on YouTube and a podcast (coming soon!), and make it possible for us to offer everything we do as accessibly as possible.
In addition to monetary gifts, consider the gift of your time as a volunteer for the Saṅgha. Volunteer work, called sevā, or "service," is a powerful and subtle practice that builds community, creates connection, and helps make the Saṅgha a spiritual home, not just a venue for teaching events. We are expanding our volunteer group, and looking for help with a number of administrative projects, including visual design, website maintenance, retreat management, and outreach. Email us if you're interested in volunteering.
Ongoing Saṅgha Spaces
Tuesdays 7:30-9pm (Pacific), weekly
Meditation, talk, discussion
Book Club: Read the Dīgha Nikāya, the Long Discourses of the Buddha
Fridays 8:30-10am (Pacific), monthly
Talk, inquiry, discussion
Saṅgha Facebook group
Recordings, discussion, Q & A
All are welcome
May our practice be of benefit to all.
0 comments