In It To End It by Sean Oakes

All issues

Right Speech, Fascism, Inflammation

It is as much a practice of right speech to understand when we are being lied to as committing to not lying ourselves.

image


Friends,


In our current study series, we've been talking about the aggregates, and how the various aspects of our experience can be fuel for clinging and distress. The ancient image is of burning firewood, with sensory contact inspiring a habitual reactivity that doesn't know how to stop. The Buddha's famous third talk begins: "All is burning. The eye is burning... the ear is burning... the mind is burning... Burning with what? With greed, hatred, and delusion."


Deluded human action has brought our world to burning, literally as wildfire and intensifying heat everywhere, and metaphorically in war and unrestrained resource extraction. The news is a wildfire of burning fuel: startling, overwhelming, and a full-time job to try to process emotionally, much less to act coherently in relation to.


For the last couple weeks at Satsang, we talked about Right Speech, and some of the political and social implications of being dedicated to the practice of speaking the truth in a skillful way. Part of where we got to is that we can think about the difficult process of relating with the larger media ecosystem as an extension of speech practice into "right listening." In a "post-truth" society—which means metastasized propaganda, and mistrust of cultural norms and legacy institutions, particularly journalism—we have to constantly bring our skill and discernment to how we receive, interpret, and transmit the messages coming at us through all the channels we interact with.


It is as much a practice of right speech to understand when we are being lied to as committing to not lying ourselves.


What the "burning" teachings point to is how sensory contact, like watching, listening to, and reading information about the world, so easily becomes fuel for our worst tendencies. We grasp at information we like, fear and reject information we don't like, and burn with confusion, anger, and despair throughout. The Buddha's solution is not to abstain from watching, listening, and reading, but to train ourselves to not grasp—to not give in to the inflammatory nature of charged information.


Over the last couple days my feeds were flooded with news about the National Guard being deployed in LA in response to anti-ICE protests there. If I only read social media, I might have been convinced that the city was being taken over at gunpoint by federal Gestapo. Reading more closely into the news revealed that most of it was threats and bluster, that the protests were largely peaceful, and that it wasn't nothing—there were protests and harsh police response—but also not as alarming as the more inflammatory stories suggested.


This is not to blame people who spread a false story unintentionally. Fear and reactivity exist in the nervous system for a reason, after all, and folks are sincerely trying to protect themselves and the culture they love. Our practice of weakening and preventing craving is essentially a kind of trauma therapy, where we see the symptoms of our ancient wounds flaring up again, exactly as inflammation is intended, wrapping around and trying to protect a new wound.


If you want to dig into the burning and craving teachings (fun, really!), you can join the NY Insight class midway. We'll look this week at Dependent Origination, which is the clearest map the Buddha offered for how craving is the hinge to existence and rebirth into more suffering. And all the previous classes are recorded, so you can binge the first 3 episodes before joining us Thu at 4pm PT.


Also, happy Pride! I'll be teaching the Spirit Rock Monday Night class on June 23 with a queer Dhamma theme.


With mettā,

Sean


PS, we have a new website! Check it out, and let us know what you think.




From Satsang, Tue 5.20.25

Right Speech and Interpretive Communities

Tonight we'll look at the Buddha's guidelines on right speech, continuing on from our conversation about relationships a couple weeks ago. Our words are often the most important way we connect with each other, but there are so many ways now for words to go wrong! We hurt each other unintentionally, add opinion or defensiveness unconsciously, or fall under the sway of politicized memes instead of speaking what is our own to express.


We'll see how far we get into this, but part of where this is going is an exploration of what it means to participate in communities of interpretation, and how through language we share one large system of understanding, or mind. Except, of course, that it's not "one" but many, and the fragmentation that has come with the siloed communication of the social media era means that statements of truth are now fragile in a way that they haven't been before.


The standard progressive critique to the right wing idea that truth is malleable is to insist that it is not: that there is such a thing as a fact, and that it can be reported accurately, without excessive distortion through a politicized lens. This is true for a certain narrow type of fact, but unfortunately for progressive politics, it is less true than we might wish it to be.


The Buddhist understanding that all experiences are conditioned and contingent upon context plays easily into the claim that truth is whatever you perceive it to be. We have to deconstruct this elision if we want to not end up mistakenly agreeing with the right by misinterpreting emptiness. Deconstructing communication is part of mindfulness of the aggregates because everything we say or hear is a saṅkhāra, or karmic formation—stories are mental constructs that reflect the conditions through which they come into being. Basically—and this is the definition of positionality—who you are conditions what you are able to think, and by extension describe your experience in words.


So other than the absolute truth that no words can describe, everything can and will be described differently by different people. The "post-truth" world is radical, not because truth is somehow different than it ever was before, but because it politicizes difference. A wise Buddhist understanding of emptiness avoids the trap by understanding that just because everything is contingent doesn't mean experiences are meaningless or infinitely malleable. Deconstruction just helps us be clearer about what levels of rhetoric we're speaking through—distinguishing between description, interpretation, opinion, research, etc.


We'll start tonight with the Buddha's basic definition of right speech, and go on from there to explore some of these deeper threads in communication, interpretive community, and culture.


Meditation: How We Speak To Ourselves


Talk: Right Speech and Interpretive Communities




From Satsang, Tue 5.27.25

Right Speech under Fascism

One of the things authoritarian systems always do is police language. To have language for an experience creates the ability to think about it, which creates the possibility of doing something about it. In order to act together, which is the action that's needed, we need language to talk to each other about what's happening. If a fascist government convinces us to use their words for what's happening, they have succeeded in reducing us to acting within their frameworks and understanding.


The Buddha's guidelines on speech support us in resistance to fascist language, most importantly by understanding that euphemisms for horrors are a way to lie—to direct attention away from the horror. Calling a genocide a genocide, or a regressive tax a regressive tax, is central to protect protecting our ability to resist to these kinds of violence.


We'll continue our discussion of right speech tonight looking at political—and politicized—speech particularly, and how our practice of speaking the truth as skillfully as possible, and listening critically, is a form of resistance and radical compassion.


Meditation: Feeling the Impact of Narratives


Talk: Right Speech Under Fascism




Teaching Schedule


Seeing the Dhamma: How Practice Leads to Understanding

Sutta Study Series 3

May 22 - Jun 19, 2025 | 4-5:30pm PT | New York Insight, online

Register


Queer Dhamma: The Dhamma is Always Already Queer!

Spirit Rock Monday Night Meditation & Talk

Jun 23, 2025 | 6:30-8:30pm PT | Spirit Rock, online and ON LAND!

Register


See All




Ongoing Saṅgha Spaces

Insight Meditation Satsang

Tuesdays 7:30-9pm (Pacific), weekly

Meditation, talk, discussion


Book Club: Read the Dīgha Nikāya, the Long Discourses of the Buddha

Fridays 8:30-10am (Pacific), monthly

Talk, inquiry, discussion

Next session: Fri June 20


In It To End It

Saṅgha Facebook group

Recordings, discussion, Q & A

All are welcome



Join the Saṅgha




Dāna

We are in the process of changing our subscription structure, and you're getting other notes about the new model. Thank you to everyone who gave feedback on the new Saṅgha access structure. The donation page is mostly the same, but let us know if anything doesn't work the way you expect it to! Thank you.


Donate Here



May our practice be of benefit to all.




SeanFeitOakes.com

YouTube | Insight Timer | Instagram

Share
Get the next issue in your inbox
Free, and you can unsubscribe any time.

0 comments

More issues

All 95 →
#52 Jun 8, 2025

Your Saṅgha Access subscription

Read issue →
#51 May 16, 2025

New study series starts May 22! and "The Sweet Fragrance of the Buddha"

Read issue →