Friends,
It's been a delight to be talking through Yoga history and the postmodern chaos of contemporary spirituality at the Tuesday Satsang, and about attention training in the NY Insight class. Then I go over to FB—my feed is almost entirely alarmed commentary on the US coup—or read the news and have another wave of doubt. This thing I've been doing of trying to balance obsessing about the global disaster that is this political moment and continuing with our Dhamma investigation and inner practice: is it skillful? Should I drop the themes I've been teaching on for the moment and encourage focusing all our collective energy on the crisis? I basically flip-flop on this weekly.
This doubt is everywhere in my communities at the moment, and absolutely natural, I think. I hear it in your questions and our discussions of practice all the time. What is the right balance of inner and outer attention for each of us, in this disorienting moment, and in the next, and the next?
We know that political, military, and economic crisis is an ongoing part of our world, so there is strong contemplative justification for mostly letting it sort itself out and staying close to the task of inner cultivation. We know the resilience and wisdom our practice grows is absolutely necessary for our own well-being in the long run and our ability to help others around us. But there are at least two other strong justifications pulling on our psyches.
When danger becomes local, there is a natural urge to help those around us stay safe. This is the active compassion that brings us to engaging in our immediate communities—joining with those who are tracking ICE raids or showing up at city council meetings to hold off what we can of the many-tentacled monster and not lose the culture war by giving up. This is an activism that stays close to the nervous system—to our instinctual need to protect those we care about in the immediate ecosystem.
The other force that pulls on us, though, is more distant, and is based on the profound but complex abstraction called "democracy." Whether or not you live in a healthy or unhealthy democracy, the idea has been planted deep in our collective imagination that we have the power, collectively, to change the political situation we live under. In so many ways that weren't possible in the ancient world, we do—this is what we mean by democracy. I think it is partly because of this that we have this doubt about social engagement as the opposite of contemplative spirituality. If we have the power to change an unjust situation, after all, shouldn't doing so be our primary concern?
The Buddha didn't try to overthrow the local murderous, imperial king Ajatasattu partly because his spiritual wisdom had other methods (he tried, with imperfect success, to convert him to the Dhamma), but also because people didn't overthrow kings in those days. It wasn't part of the collective consciousness that you could do that. But now that we have a great set of idealistic revolutions, but also just positive democratic processes, in our rearview mirror, we've been trained to feel the naturalness and rightness of the democratic process. We feel like we can have a voice in the affairs of the state, and that becomes the idea that we should exercise that voice, which can lead to the conclusion that doing so—because it seems to address most directly the suffering of the world—is the best use of our time and energy. Basically, the sense of empowerment that democracy gives us also leads to the doubt about whether it's ethical to focus on anything other than politics, since politics is where the biggest harms and potentials for good both reside.
We'll see where this doubt takes me this week, meaning that I'm not sure if tomorrow's discussion at Satsang will be about this, and about political engagement, or if it will go back to our exploration of the roots of healthy individual practice we've been on since January. Either way, blessings as you navigate the choice points that mark your own path through the chaos of the moment, and in both the inner work and outer service that you find most nourishing for you.
With mettā,
Sean
* I didn't get a newsletter out last week, so below are the writings and recordings from 2 weeks of Satsang conversations on Yoga history and postmodernity in Yoga and the culture more broadly.
From Satsang, Tue 3.4.25
A Mini-history of Yoga as Exercise, Part 2
Continuing with our overview of Yoga history focusing on the postural and exercise aspects, we look at the influence of the colonial British and European empires on physical practice in South Asia. Yoga as we know it in its current globalized, commercialized form is a product of late 20th century capitalism, which we can trace back to the orientalist subculture of the 1960s (which began 100 years earlier in the Victorian era) and maybe peaked with the Instagram influencer performance Yoga of the 2010s. But its roots are in the British empire, under which an Indian resistance drew on its ancient heritage of inner cultivation practices to craft new forms of both religious practice and physical training. These new Yogas both appropriated from colonial forms—like the YMCA calisthenics and European circus contortion tricks that famously made their way into the modern āsana collection—and innovated on their ancestral models, developing the āsana-based Yoga that is most known now, even in India itself.
The heat from an initial flareup of concern around cultural appropriation in American Yoga seems to have died down from its peak about a decade ago, perhaps because the culture war moved on to new, more inflammatory subjects. What I see now is a Yoga culture where some schools and teachers are obviously fluent in the issues around cultural appropriation and colonialism more broadly, and these schools tend to be aligned in the US with the social justice left. And other schools and teachers, particularly in the more New Age side of progressive culture, appear to have never gotten the memo, and continue with orientalist approaches to South Asian content as if there was never a critical conversation at all. I suspect most of these folks simply don't know that there was a critical conversation, or if they do, they have not been connected to communities that have taught them to take these critiques seriously.
We can call the recent history of Yoga (and many other colonial phenomena) a phase of postmodernization characterized by the fracturing of large-scale influential lineages into innumerable schools and approaches, a relativistic approach to culture and multiculturalism, and an embrace of the infinite differentiation created by awareness of social location and personality. All of this has changed Yoga as a physical discipline, certainly in the hyper-postmodern progressive subculture places like northern California, where I live. Folks who really wanted Yoga to be strength training peeled off into Pilates and Cross Fit, while folks who wanted it to be a vehicle for ecstatic devotional states found their home in bhakti lineages or in psychedelic work. Almost nobody I know still believes that stretching-based postural work is either good exercise or spiritually potent by itself.
We can see this realization emerging in both post-colonial posture-based Yoga and post-colonial meditation-based Buddhisms like Insight Meditation/vipassanā. A technique was abstracted from its South Asian religious home—sometimes by Europeans and Americans, sometimes by Asian teachers themselves, but both under colonial influence—found to be useful by itself, turned into a branch of the religion (and called "spiritual" instead of "religious"), and then discovered by sincere devotees to be lacking essential elements of a spiritual path. Those devotees then either go back to the source tradition and attempt to bring more of it into the new branch, or go looking from outside the tradition for what is missing. So we have a profusion of mixed lineages, non-lineages, and infinitely fractured micro-communities. That's the postmodern condition.
In both Yoga and Insight Meditation, I'm among the "go back to the source and try to bring a more complete religious framework into the globalized postmodern form" contingent. This doesn't mean I'm going to encourage you to sever your lingual frenulum so that you can liberate your tongue to turn back into the nasal cavity for the practice of khecarī mudrā, but I do know contemporary yogis who have done that and experienced significant benefit! I do encourage us to investigate the practices we are drawn to, both in internal somatic and meditative inquiry and in external historical and cultural exploration. This precious human birth, as they call it, is short, and to waste any of it thinking we're developing ourselves either physically or spiritually but actually doing something that is of dubious benefit is really a shame.
Meditation: Ujjayi as a Meditation Breath
Talk: A Mini-history of Yoga as Exercise, Part 2
From Satsang, Tue 3.11.25
Post-colonial, Postmodern Post-"yoga" Yoga
Tonight we'll look at some of the difficult questions unearthed in our last two episodes on the history of the physical Yogas. The last couple decades have of course seen all the big social movements — #MeToo, #BLM, and more — reproduced in global Yoga communities, not just as scandals and canceling people, though lots of that, but also in the kind of self-critical introspection that interrogating post-colonial cultural artifacts always gives rise to. We look at some of this in historical context, including cultural appropriation, the end of lineages, and the turn in culture and conscious social practice known as the postmodern.
Meditation: Grounding with Ujjayi and Box Breathing
Talk: Post-colonial, Postmodern Post-"yoga" Yoga
Teaching Schedule
Rebuild Your Attention: Buddhist Practices for Focus, Clarity, and Joy
A 5-week study class at New York Insight
5 Thursdays, Feb 27 – Mar 27, 2025 | 3:30-5pm PT | Online
Has begun but still possible to register
Deepening Practice: Quieting Our Minds and Opening our Hearts in Community
Gay Buddhist Fellowship Spring Retreat for queer male-identified practitioners
Apr 23-27, 2025 | Vajrapani Institute
Dāna
Our ability to offer as much as we can in this beautiful tradition of gift economy depends on your support. Your gifts make scholarships possible for those with less resources to attend retreat, support our preservation of the teaching archive, and make it possible for us to offer everything we do as accessibly as possible. Thank you.
Ongoing Saṅgha Spaces
Tuesdays 7:30-9pm (Pacific), weekly
Meditation, talk, discussion
Book Club: Read the Dīgha Nikāya, the Long Discourses of the Buddha
Fridays 8:30-10am (Pacific), monthly
Talk, inquiry, discussion
Next session: Fri Mar 28
Saṅgha Facebook group
Recordings, discussion, Q & A
All are welcome
May our practice be of benefit to all.
0 comments