Hi ,
Ray runs an eight-bay auto repair shop outside Tulsa. About 900 tickets a month, average repair around $340. Almost every one of those cars needs a cabin air filter, new wiper blades, or an alignment check. His team almost never brings it up.
Not because they don't notice. Because asking feels like piling on to someone who just agreed to pay $340 for something they didn't want to pay for in the first place. The card is already out. Nobody wants to be the one who asks for more.
Here's what that instinct costs him. About 34% of customers say yes to an add-on when someone actually asks at the moment of purchase. If his writers offered one $60 add-on on half of those 900 tickets a month, at a 34% yes rate, that's over $9,000 a month left on the table. Not from new customers. From the ones already standing at the counter with their card out.
I get why owners skip this. A price objection feels like your price is too high. It usually means your offer gave the customer nothing else to talk about. But an add-on offered right after a yes is a different conversation. You're not pitching a stranger. You're serving someone who already trusts you enough to hand over their car and their card.
There's a reason the retention math backs this up too. A repeat buyer is 60 to 70% likely to buy from you again. A stranger walking in cold sits at 5 to 20%. You already paid to win this customer once. The add-on at the close costs you nothing more to offer. It's the cheapest revenue in the business, and most owners ring up the sale and go quiet instead of reaching for it.
The fix isn't a laminated menu of ten upsells for your team to memorize. It's one add-on, one sentence, asked the same way every time, in the same spot in the visit. Ray picked the cabin air filter on any ticket over $200 and wrote the exact question his writers ask while walking the customer to the counter. His average ticket moved less than sixty dollars per invoice. Across 900 tickets a month, that was his best month without adding a single new customer.
In the full article, I walk through the three-step way to build this into your own shop, plus the exact sentence Ray uses so you're not starting from a blank page.
Read the full breakdown here: https://www.profit-sensei.com/post/upsell-customers-small-business
Not sure which part of your business is leaking the most revenue right now? The Profit Drivers Scorecard takes three minutes and names your weakest of five growth drivers.
Take the scorecard: https://www.profit-sensei.com/scorecard
Kumar
Profit Sensei
0 comments