How I used to feel about my “sense of sin” (yikes)

Aug 31, 2025 9:01 am

Hi ~


Here’s Matthew 3:1–2:


In those days John the Baptist came preaching in the wilderness of Judea, saying, “Repent, for the kingdom of heaven is at hand.”


And here’s the note I wrote next to that verse in my wide-margin Bible back in 1993 when I was 35:


“This ‘Repent’ contains with it the urgency that the sinner have a strong sense of his sin and its atrocity before God. This is the sense that I need to have in order to have a truly right relationship with Him.”


When I reread that note more than 30 years later, I said out loud, “Wow.”


Months later, when I came back to it again while preparing to write this email, I said “Wow” again.


Not because I was impressed with my insight, haha.


No, I was astounded at my brainwashing.


Here’s why:


If you’ve read the chapter on “metanoia” in Untwisting Scriptures Book 4, you already know that the Greek word translated “repent” isn’t primarily about sin at all.


That truth alone was a major paradigm shift for me.


But there was something else at work in my thinking.


I believed that in order to have a right relationship with God, I needed to carry around a constant, crushing sense of how atrocious my sin was.


Can you see how twisted that is?


Where did that belief even come from?


As far as I can remember, it was the only way of thinking I’d ever heard or read (aside from a few bright spots here and there that didn't quite sink in to my brainwashed head).


It wasn't until about 10 years later--10 years after I wrote that note--that this twisted view began to unravel for me.


And another 10 years before it became clear enough to write about in a way that others could understand.


To go from


“I must stay bowed down very low before God, always conscious of my vile sin”


to


“I am a beloved daughter of God, and I can come joyfully and boldly into His presence through my Lord Jesus”


that is a journey of freedom and healing, through His truth.


If you haven’t yet read the chapter in Untwisting Scriptures Book 4 that explores what “repentance” really means, you can get that book here.


If you’re like me, having a right understanding of the New Testament word translated repentance could change your life too.


It’s a journey, for sure. But what a worthwhile one.


With you in hope for your own untwisting journey,

Rebecca

Untwisting Scriptures at heresthejoy.com

See my Untwisting Scriptures series

Trauma-informed Christian book coach at Rebecca Davis WordWorking


Is this email helpful? Pass it on to a friend!


Sign up for my regular emails here:


Get the Tiny Untwistings





Note: If you purchase from links in my emails, I may receive a commission, but it is at no additional cost to you.

Comments
avatar Pat Massi
I am visiting local churches to see if I can find one closer to home. For 2 weeks I have visited a church where, for an hour and 45 minutes each week, sin, and the fact that Jesus had to die for us wicked sinners was ground into me with condemnation. I absolutely cannot go back. Your article is blessed sanity. Thank you, Rebecca.